Wednesday, January 15, 2020
Isolation in Hardyââ¬â¢s poems ââ¬ËNobody Comesââ¬â¢ and ââ¬ËThe Darkling Thrushââ¬â¢ Essay
In the poems ââ¬Å"The Darkling Thrushâ⬠[ââ¬ËTDTââ¬â¢] and ââ¬Å"Nobody Comesâ⬠[ââ¬ËNCââ¬â¢], Hardy presents two similar images of isolation. In both poems, the personae are isolated from human company, whilst Hardy explores this using imagery of ghosts and the supernatural in both also. However, individually there are differences in tone; although NC ends upon as dire a note as it begins, Hardy engineers an optimistic outlook in TDT and suggests that the personaââ¬â¢s isolation may not Hardy ensures that the persona of ââ¬ËTDTââ¬â¢ is isolated from any other human presence or, until the poemââ¬â¢s third stanza, any living organism. Whilst leaning against ââ¬Å"a coppice gateâ⬠, he notes that ââ¬Å"all mankindâ⬠¦ had sought their household firesâ⬠. Although this is an indication of the low temperature, it is noticeable that the rest of humanity are seeking light in an otherwise dark environment; reciprocally, the persona is deprived of both warmth and living company. To further this point, Hardy personifies non-human entities, such as frost and winter ââ¬â ââ¬Å"Winterââ¬â¢s dregsâ⬠, for example. In this way, Hardy makes the reader personal not with living creatures but with inanimate entities, isolating the animate persona even more. Indeed, Hardy makes such a division more striking by picturing the personaââ¬â¢s surroundings as very extreme. Surrounded by deathly imagery, the persona imagines the landscape as ââ¬Å"the Centuryââ¬â¢s corpse/ His crypt the canopy,/ The wind his death lamentâ⬠. Even Hardyââ¬â¢s animate entities seem ghostly; ââ¬Å"Frost was spectre-grayâ⬠and ââ¬Å"mankindâ⬠¦ haunted nighâ⬠. Such is the state of decay that even ââ¬Å"the ancient pulse of germ and birth was shrunkenâ⬠ââ¬â the regenerative power of life has itself died, leaving the persona as the sole animate existence. A similar loneliness can be seen in ââ¬ËNCââ¬â¢, especially towards the end of the poem. In the aftermath of the car passing, the persona observes, ââ¬Å"mute by the gateâ⬠, that he ââ¬Å"stand[s] again alone.â⬠The sudden silence and soft, finite ââ¬Ëtââ¬â¢ sound of ââ¬Å"muteâ⬠ââ¬â in contrast to the onomatopoeic ââ¬Å"whangsâ⬠ââ¬â amplifies the personaââ¬â¢s loneliness; as does the empty assonance in the repeated ââ¬Ëaââ¬â¢ sound, in ââ¬Å"aloneâ⬠and ââ¬Å"againâ⬠. Equally, the present tense verb ââ¬Å"standsâ⬠and ââ¬Å"againâ⬠emphasizes that this is an ongoing and repeated state of isolation. However, the persona in ââ¬ËNobody Comesââ¬â¢ is not simply isolated in terms of being physically alone or the sole living creature ââ¬â he is also isolated from modernity. Hardy again uses ââ¬Ësupernaturalââ¬â¢ imagery to explore this. The persona notes that ââ¬Å"The telegraph wireâ⬠¦ intonesâ⬠¦ like a spectral lyre/ Swept by a spectral handâ⬠. Rather than see the telegraph wire as a means of communication, the persona rejects it in presenting an image of disassociation; the vagueness of the verb ââ¬Å"intonesâ⬠summons an image of faceless voices. He also creates negative supernatural connotations; there is an innate ghostliness about the archaic lyre ââ¬â juxtaposed to contrast with the innate modernity of the telegraph wire ââ¬â which is reinforced by the wraithlike ââ¬Å"spectralâ⬠. Hardy repeats this for emphasis in ââ¬Å"spectral handâ⬠. In this phrase, he also creates an incongruity between the concrete verb ââ¬Å"sweptâ⬠and noun ââ¬Å"handâ⬠and the abstract concept of ââ¬Å"ghostlinessâ⬠ââ¬â the ââ¬Ëhandââ¬â¢ does not exist. Its invisible presence and visible effects are unnerving, making the modern telegraph wire an unpleasant image. The personaââ¬â¢s rejection of modernity can be seen also in the depiction of ââ¬Å"a car com[ing] upâ⬠. Having shone its aggressive lamps at ââ¬Å"full glareâ⬠ââ¬â which Hardy emphasizes by placing at the end of the line ââ¬âthe persona states that ââ¬Å"it has nothing to do with meâ⬠. This maxim, in being so blunt, is very powerful. It operates to present a rift between the persona and the modern world and, given the unusually colloquial verb ââ¬Å"whangsâ⬠, it indicates that the car is viewed as a callous representation of modern life from which the persona wishes to isolate himself. It leaves ââ¬Å"leaving a blacker airâ⬠, which may indicate either a corruption of nature (in terms of polluting the otherwise fresh air) or a darkening in the personaââ¬â¢s emotions. Indeed, the poem concludes with the same negativity, with the word ââ¬Å"nobodyâ⬠in both the title and the last line. The persona is left ââ¬Å"again aloneâ⬠and isolated, prompting a large amount of sympathy from the reader. By contrast, ââ¬ËTDTââ¬â¢ concludes with a hopeful note. At the appearance of the thrush, in the third stanza, the reader notes that the bird is similarly isolated and surrounded by death. In truth, the readerââ¬â¢s initial reaction to the ââ¬Å"agedâ⬠¦ frail, gaunt and smallâ⬠thrush is to question whether the creature will survive the bleak conditions. There is a sense of desperation present ââ¬Å"fling[ing its] soul/ Upon the growing gloom.â⬠However, the persona notices ââ¬Å"some blessed Hopeâ⬠in the birdââ¬â¢s ââ¬Å"happy good-night airâ⬠. Although ââ¬Å"unawareâ⬠of why this may be ââ¬â such ââ¬Å"joy illimitedâ⬠is unintelligible to the persona ââ¬â this leads the poem to end in an optimistic fashion. Although both the persona and the thrush remain isolated from any other company (the persona fails to deeply associate with the bird) and the anxiety about the future lingers, Hardy does much to suggest that such deep rooted ââ¬Å"fervourlessnessâ⬠may change in TDTââ¬â¢s persona, as opposed to the ongoing isolation present in NC.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.